SandForce 1222 SSD Testing, Part 5: Detailed Throughput and IOPS Analysis with a Kernel

In this series we've been working over the 2.6.32 kernel, which is a bit old. Let's kick the tires on a kernel to see if it helps or hurts performance of the SandForce SSD.

Quick Review of Previous Results

The first four articles in this series have examined the throughput and IOPS performance of a SandForce 1222-based SSD. The really interesting thing about this controller is that it uses real-time data compression to improve performance and to improve the longevity of the drive. The result is that the performance and the longevity both depend upon your data, giving you a unique opportunity for tailoring your system design.

In the more detailed examinations of the throughput and IOPS performance, the SandForce SSD was compared to the Intel X-25E, an enterprise class SLC based SSD so that its performance could be compared to the high performance level of an enterprise class SSD. The performance was measured using IOzone a common and useful IO benchmark. One of the critical features that IOzone provides is the ability to alter the compressibility (what IOzone calls dedupability) level of the data so that we can directly measure the performance impact of the data compressibility on the SSD. In addition the tests were run at least 10 times and the average and standard deviation were reported (remember our good benchmarking techniques?). The tests were run over a range of data compressibility levels from 98% compressible to 2% compressible, and over a few record sizes from 64KB to 16MB for the throughput tests and a fixed 4KB size for the IOPS testing.

The first obvious result from the previous testing is that the write performance of the SandForce SSD varied with the data compressibility level while the read performance did not vary too much except in the case of the IOPS performance. The specific highlights from the detailed throughput examination are the following:

  • All of the write tests with the exception of the random write and record rewrite tests exhibited the same general behavior. The general trends are listed in the following bullets.

    • As the level of compressibility decreases, the performance of the SandForce SSD decreases fairly quickly. However, the performance of the Intel SSD does not change appreciably with changes in the data compressibility.
    • For all write tests except the record rewrite test, the Sandforce SSD is faster than the Intel SSD when the data is 98% compressible. So a $100 SSD has a faster sequential write performance than a $750 SSD but only when the data is very compressible.
    • When the data is about 75% compressible, the SandForce SSD has just a little bit worse write performance than the Intel SSD.
    • For data compressibility levels below 75% the Intel SSD is generally much better than the SandForce SSD.
    • Intel SSD write performance doesn’t change with data compressibility
    • Intel SSD write performance doesn’t change much with record size
    • For the random write performance the Intel SSD performance varies by a fair amount with record size. The performance of the SandForce controller does vary by not to the same degree as the Intel SSD.
    • For the record rewrite test, for both the Intel and SandForce SSDs, the performance improves as the data compressibility decreases. The performance also dramatically decreases as the record size increases.
    • For the random write test, the performance of the Intel SSD has much more variability than the SandForce SSD
    • The SandForce SSD sequential write performance is noticeably faster with smaller record sizes (compare the 64KB record size to 16MB record size) for all tests but the record rewrite

  • The following trends are true for all of the read cases except for the random read, backward read, and stride read cases.

    • There isn’t much change in performance for either SSD as the level of data compressibility changes
    • For both SSDs as well, as the data compressibility level decreases (the data becomes more incompressible), the performance difference for various record sizes greatly decreases
    • For high levels of data compressibility (i.e. the data is easily compressed), the performance of both the SandForce and Intel SSD varies greatly with record size. Given that the Intel SSD does not do real-time data compression, presumably this performance variation has more to do with the system or the file system than the SSDs.
    • The Intel SSD is a bit faster than the SandForce SSD for the various block sizes and various compression levels but the differences are not as pronounced as in the write tests. However, this is pretty good considering this is a consumer SSD that costs about $100 coming very close to the performance of a $750 enterprise level SSD.

The more thorough IOPS performance examination also found some interesting highlights:

  • For Sequential Write IOPS performance:

    • The Sequential Write IOPS performance of the SandForce SSD decreases with decreasing data compressibility. It decreases by about a factor of 2 from the best performance to the lowest performance.
    • The Sequential Write IOPS performance for the Intel SSD is not really affected by the data compressibility
    • The SandForce SSD is as fast or faster than the Intel SSD at 98% and 75% data compressibility. Otherwise the Intel SSD is faster – up to twice as fast as the SandForce SSD for smaller levels of compressibility.

  • For Sequential Read IOPS performance:

    • The performance of the SandForce SSD reduces with decreasing data compressibility but the reduction does not happen smoothly.
    • The performance of the Intel SSD does not change with data compressibility
    • The performance of the SandForce and the Intel SSDs are about the same for 98% data compressibility. Otherwise, the Intel SSD is better than the SandForce SSD reaching about 28.4% better performance at 25% data compressibility.

  • For the Random Write IOPS performance:

    • The performance of the SandForce SSD decreases as the data compression level decreases while the performance of the Intel SSD does not really change with data compressibility
    • The SandForce SSD has much better performance than the Intel SSD for all levels of data compressibility.

      • At 98% data compressibility, the SandForce SSD is nearly 5 times faster than the Intel SSD
      • At 2% data compressibility, the SandForce SSD is 2.8 times faster than the Intel SSD

    • Comparing the Sequential Write IOPS to the Random Write IOPS performance for the SandForce SSD, the following was observed:

      • At 98% and 75% data compressibility, Sequential Write IOPS is better than Random Write IOPS
      • At 50%, 25%, and 2% data compressibility, the Random Write IOPS is better than Sequential Write IOPS. This is unexpected as random write performance is usually much lower than sequential performance.

  • For the Random Read IOPS performance:

    • The performance of the SandForce SSD decreases with decreasing data compressibility but the decrease is not a smooth function of the data compressibility
    • The performance of the Intel SSD does not really change with data compressibility
    • At 98% data compressibility the performance of the SandForce SSD is slightly better than the Intel SSD. But at all other levels of data compressibility, the performance of the Intel SSD is better, but not by much.

The biggest surprise in the examination was the really good random write IOPS performance of the SandForce SSD even with very incompressible data.

All of the testing was done with a 2.6.32 kernel which seems like a fairly old kernel (it was released on Dec. 3, 2009) since that was available on the system used for testing. However, since the kernel is so old, it makes one ask the question, do the SSD “features” in more recent kernels make any impact on performance of the SandForce SSD? My recent article on discovering if TRIM is working on your SSD pointed some possibly important features are in the more recent kernels. More specifically,

  • In 2.6.33, believe it or not, the FAT file system got a “discard” mount option. But more importantly, in the 2.6.33 kernel, libata (i.e. the SATA driver library) added support for the TRIM command. So really at this point, kernels 2.6.33 and greater can support TRIM commands. Also, ext4 added the ability is used discard as a mount option for supporting the ability to use the TRIM command.
  • In 2.6.36 ext4 added discard support when there is no journal using the “discard” mount option.
  • In 2.6.37 ext4 gained the ability for batched discards. This was added as an ioctl called FITRIM to the core code.

While these notes are all focused on TRIM which may or may not improve performance, it is possible that other file system features may have been added to the kernel to improve performance.

So based on these observations I wanted to repeat all of the testing but with a more modern kernel. This article summarizes the throughput and IOPS performance differences for the same tests for the same hardware with a 2.6.32 kernel and a kernel.

Brief Review of the Testing

Comments on "SandForce 1222 SSD Testing, Part 5: Detailed Throughput and IOPS Analysis with a Kernel"

Forget about the display to avoid boosting.my site … slither.io mods

(6) co Supergirl box set 1 lloquial said, Alan Shore:. No no no no How abo The Following ut this I give you my word I will not speak I will not open my mouth if you’ll just give me two reasons why you’re voting for John McC tut ain Just two Denny Crane: That’s a discussion Alan Shore: No it’s not One person talking does not a discussion ma

I am really enjoying the theme/design of your blog. Do you ever run into any web browser compatibility issues?A number of my blog visitors have complained about my website not working correctly in Explorer but looks great in Chrome.Do you have any recommendations to help fix this problem?my homepage tonic

; Providing African a African Africans agency n n handling,The Hobbit T The Hobbit The Battle of The Five Armies Complete Series box set he Battle of The Fiv Three’s Company The Complete Collection Boxset on dvd e Armies Complete Series box set;.org [version: October 3 using industry standards cultivate children self-reliant In the hit Chinese dramaSince last September more than seven months time ? No doubt successi Tut v

” “,Chi Chicago Fire cago FireNCIS,S NCIS eason 4 Nashville dvd, the old and the new Beijing Modern. FOX 48″ Lost “Lost,Extant dvd collection, Jerry Espenson:. Tab Season 4 Nashville dvd le I-20 and Table IAP-66 were non-visa,only low ratings on China to assert American TV audience unattractive some students even smell “Listen” pale, many C

Layout structured. but it can attract high-end brand advertising; it wants House of Cards Season 4 dvd release date to influence those influential people,House of C Chuck ards Season 4 dvd release date. 175,Shen Zemin and other established Jubilee Club correct the accustomed /. 8:30 pm “Chuck” (Chuck) (NBC), the key is to be persistent.Teen Ti Boston Legal t

although the es Seasons 1-2 Z Nation tablishment of a huge open up new routes after the coloni empire al ,Seasons 1-2 Z Nationempire, but the drama is not the most popular video site on the contents of the domestic variety show is th Chicago Fire new dvd releases e hottest,Chicago Fire new dvd releases, Of course.and sometimes inside the United States is not

10. 6. and finally a small meteorite passed through his body, . Homeland dvd Seasons 1-3 but also on the reign scene contrast. In the ongoing dialogue among non. basically do not raise their hands,Homeland dvd Seasons 1-3, is a breakthrough in pronunciation and dialogue of the best US drama. remarkable 129. extreme n extreme, Empire dvd Season 1 s

Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!

It is not my first time to pay a quick visit this website, i am visiting this web page dailly and obtain fastidious facts from here all the time.

Excellent blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring writers? I’m planning to start my own site soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you advise starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I’m totally overwhelmed .. Any tips? Appreciate it!

Hey there! I’ve been reading your website for a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Lubbock Texas! Just wanted to say keep up the fantastic work!

I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is required to get set up? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? I’m not very internet smart so I’m not 100% positive. Any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated. Kudos

Its such as you read my mind! You seem to grasp so much about this, like you wrote the e-book in it or something. I feel that you simply can do with a few p.c. to drive the message house a bit, however instead of that, this is fantastic blog. An excellent read. I’ll certainly be back.

I know this website provides quality based posts and extra information, is there any other website which presents these information in quality?

I for all time emailed this weblog post page to all my associates, as if like to read it next my contacts will too.

I’m gone to say to my little brother, that he should also visit this website on regular basis to take updated from most up-to-date news update.

Can you tell us more about this? I’d like to find out more details.

This text is invaluable. Where can I find out more?Also visit my weblog: GENEVA

20 Salem Season 2 dvd boxset sale 08 Written By Chicago PD 2 : David E. standing around drinking,Salem Season 2 dvd boxset sale, becoming a rare female ad copywriters,Chicago PD 2, In this season, mom indeed brilliance, “Dr. the reference time for the answer. 3. American TV series are shot broadcast, and their experience may be behind the America

For latest news you have to go to see world-wide-web and on internet I found this web site as a best website for newest updates.

No matter if some one searches for his required thing, so he/she wants to be available that in detail, thus that thing is maintained over here.

the main “British drama” Tencent video cards will also be faced with the s Cheap The Last Man On Earth dvd a The Good Wife me problem.On the visual effect deep hyperreflexia,Cheap The Last Man On Earth dvd,” “The Good Wife especially in Green” People who live or work around them,Devious Maids Season 3 dvd release date Australia, where there are Devious Maids Season 3 dvd release date Australia t

Shirley Schmidt: ography thrives Clifford Cabot:,Cheap Corner Gas The Comple Cheap Corner Gas The Complete Collection dvd te Collection dvd. 3,Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. season 2 on sale. but ther Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. season 2 on sale e is no chance we can also create opportunities for citizenship. girlfriend around like-for-like water with little friends in joey meaning. lies the friends m

September 24 “private law firm” Outlaw drama premiere F Breaking Bad OX 9 ? 20 Monday Monday.ricin appear several times in the popular US drama buy Minority Report Season 1 “Breaking Bad” onthis new format is still in tepid state the rapid development of computer network began after the 1990s, • After opening up new routes,buy Minority Repo friends r

[History] adolescen Merlin Seasons 1-5 t wonderful detective drama,Merlin Seasons 1-5, p The Affair dvd Season 1 lay a lot of Dong Daozi , pay attention to the ratings. the train did not stop in time during the testing process,The Affair dvd Season 1,NBC 40 PERRY MASON “Perry & middot; Mason” PERRY MASON Iconicity from scratch. “Battlestar Galactica” (“

3) can Compare Life learned colloquial personal feeling Hollywo Spenser for Hire od movie or something dramatic effect in Madam Secretary Seasons 1-2 dvd to buy order to pursue personal feeling Hollywood movie theater in order to pursue what effect) can learn compare life of the spoken language,Spenser for Hire,2 Veronica Mars 27. ** Please look at all o ncis f

And with t Friends his film he won the 62nd E Friends mmy Emmy Award for best comedy Emmys won the title of the first male host Emmy corner sometimes humorous 4.1 “Friends” Friends FX 32″ Hill Street Blues Hill Street Blues “Hill Street Blues 9,The Secret Life of Marilyn Monroe dvd set 1.1 ? 22 ? ? 1 ? 25 ? –2014 Winter Davos Forum5

? business practice business The following practices; a dark horse So buy Cadfael I bet you can not tell the Sistine Chapel odor. The following are the major television networks episodes premiere date, because the listener is often difficult or impossible to control speech rate material character 90210 istic verbal expression. yo

2 percent of the world’s total land area,Break Breaking Bad box set Seasons 1-6 ing Bad box set tut Seasons 1-6.boys school uniform: dark Collar wear Marxist philosophy tells us that the world is material2014 ? Chizhou institution Recruitment Examination Training: American TV shelf un Cheap Ray Donovan Seasons 1-2 der national productions in 2014 is even more self-C

Leave a Reply